
Karsen Trull, from CAGE International, says the government’s new definition of anti-Muslim hostility is a sham, designed to avoid confronting the institutional Islamophobia embedded in the very state policies that target British Muslims.
A mosque in the UK is now targeted every five days, and hate crimes against Muslims are at their highest level on record, up 15% in a single year. For any other community, this would be treated as a national emergency. For Muslims, in the middle of Islamophobia Awareness Month, the government’s answer is a definition that will not even use the word Islamophobia.
A new report from CAGE International, published last week, examines that definition in detail. Its conclusion is that the government does not misunderstand Islamophobia. It refuses to name it, because naming it honestly would point straight back at the state.
The “anti-Muslim hostility” definition, unveiled in March, drops the word Islamophobia entirely and ignores the fact that Muslims are targeted for who they are, not only for what they believe.
Every one of its three parts requires proof that someone intended to stir up hatred, and it goes out of its way to protect the right to ridicule and insult Islam. It carries no legal weight and offers no examples of what anti-Muslim hostility looks like in practice.
Eight months on, the “Special Representative” graciously promised to implement it still has not been appointed. In October, ministers told a selection of Muslim representatives at Downing Street that a name would be announced within the week. That week came and went.
The state is the biggest driver of Islamophobia
Subscribe to our newsletter and stay updated on the latest news and updates from around the Muslim world!
None of this is for want of knowledge. The Runnymede Trust documented Islamophobia in 1997. In 2018, more than 850 Muslim organisations and over 100 academics backed a definition recognising it as a form of racism. Successive governments chose to reject it, delay, and finally rename it.
The reason becomes clear once you look at where Islamophobia in Britain actually comes from. Its most powerful driver is not the lone attacker or the anonymous troll, serious as those threats are. It is the state itself.
After 9/11, suspicion shifted from individual “bad Muslims” to Islam itself, so that practising, devout or politically engaged Muslims became suspect simply for what they believed. Prevent is where that suspicion became law. Since 2015, teachers, doctors and even nursery staff have been legally required to watch for signs of “radicalisation.”
Prevent’s defenders now point out that far-right referrals outnumber Islamist ones, but raw numbers conceal the scale of the problem. Even when the two were roughly equal, CAGE’s research director Asim Qureshi showed that, relative to the size of each community, a Muslim child was 17 times more likely to be referred for “deradicalisation” than a white British child of no faith. The UN Special Rapporteur on counter-terrorism has found the programme discriminatory against Muslim communities.
A definition built around provable intent can never reach any of this. When a school refers a child for expressing sympathy with Palestinians, nobody has acted with “the intention of encouraging hatred.” The school is carrying out its statutory “duty,” as are the hospitals, universities and councils that do the same.
They act through the logic of a state that treats Muslim belief as inherently suspect. That is Islamophobia, and the definition has been built so that it falls outside it.

Symbolic protection, expanding state powers
The definition also arrived inside the government’s Protecting What Matters strategy. That strategy brings new powers to monitor campuses, police speaker events and shut down charities.
Muslims are offered narrow, symbolic protection on paper, while the machinery that polices their religious and political lives keeps growing. These powers are built by exploiting public fears about Muslims, and once established, they reach far beyond Muslim communities to erode everyone’s rights.
Worse, by protecting insults against Islam, the definition gives far-right propaganda a free pass, as long as it targets the faith rather than a named individual. Since 9/11, attacking Islam has been the principal way of attacking Muslims, and this definition treats that as acceptable speech.
The process behind it was no better. The Muslim Council of Britain was barred from the consultation, and responses were capped at 1,000 characters, too few to explain a single case of workplace discrimination.
The working group’s recommendations were then watered down behind closed doors. After the murder of Stephen Lawrence, Britain accepted that communities must play a central role in defining the hatred they face. For Muslims, that principle was set aside.

Muslims must define Islamophobia for themselves
The Prophet ﷺ taught that whoever sees an evil should change it with their hand, and if they cannot, then with their tongue. Drawing on more than two decades of casework with families targeted by counter-terrorism powers, CAGE’s report sets out where that change should begin.
Muslim institutions should decline to endorse the definition. The MCB and the Islamophobia Response Unit have already refused, and mosques, schools and community organisations should stand with them.
Communities should build a definition of their own, one that names the British state’s domestic and foreign policies as the root of institutional Islamophobia.
The law that already exists should be used to the full. Equality law works when it is properly applied, as the IRU’s tribunal record shows, and community legal clinics should make that route open to everyone. Those who delayed, diluted and blocked protection should be remembered at the ballot box.
The appointment of a tsar will not change any of this. No representative can make a definition designed to do nothing do something, and an appointed intermediary is no substitute for organisations with long records of serving their communities.
The message the government has sent is clear: the safety of Muslims in Britain is not a priority. Muslims do not have to accept the terms the state has set for them. If the government will not name Islamophobia, Muslims will, and naming it for what it is, and where it comes from, is where resisting it begins.















