A match made in heaven?

A match made in heaven?

Quilliam Foundation: Never has a British Muslim organisation been more reviled

Posted by

In all my years reporting on British Muslims I’ve never come across a Muslim organisation which is more reviled by all strands of the community than the Quilliam Foundation, with the possible exception of al Muhajiroun, writes Roshan Muhammed Salih.

Put ten British Muslims in a room together and you’ll get ten different opinions, that’s what happens when a community is comprised of so many sects and political inclinations. And therefore, every group seems to have its fair share of supporters and haters.

But the Quilliam Foundation has achieved something rare in British Muslim circles – it has united Muslims in condemnation and disdain.

If it had been any other Muslim organisation that had brought Tommy Robinson in from the cold yesterday perhaps the Muslim reaction to the EDL leader’s defection might have been less harsh. But because it was Quilliam everyone went on a mocking rampage.

“From one extreme to another,” yelled some; “QF is making Islamophobia mainstream,” shouted others. And my personal favourite from a Facebook post: “EDL and QF: Two cheeks of the same arse.”

Origins

Founded in 2007, Quilliam styles itself as a Muslim counter extremism think-tank with the explicit goal of removing the “poison of Islamism” from British Muslim discourse and promoting a peaceful, spiritual form of Islam which is at ease with the modern western world.

It was fronted by two “ex extremists” and Hizb ut Tahrir activists Ed Husain and Maajid Nawaz but initially struggled to make any impact because of a lack of funding.

But the pair soon spotted an opportunity to secure government backing because the state was looking for a “Muslim partner” that would deflect attention from its wars abroad and their role in fomenting growing British Muslim radicalisation. Instead the government wanted a credible partner to put the focus on the Muslim community itself. Quilliam obliged.

Maajid Nawaz of the Quilliam Foundation

Maajid Nawaz of the Quilliam Foundation

In the following years  QF pocketed around a million quid a year, Husain and Nawaz paid themselves handsome salaries, expanded the organisation and were a regular feature of BBC studios and right-wing newspaper columns.

During their heyday they managed to annoy virtually every strand of British Muslim opinion from the salafis to the ikhwaanis and other Islamists, but also the  Sufis and the apolitical.

They did this by attacking virtually every active Muslim group and harping on relentlessly about Muslim extremism, while ignoring or minimizing the impact of British foreign policy. And they did this while pocketing a hefty cheque from the British government while implausibly claiming to be maintaining a distance from it.

But by 2010 the British government funding had dried up because of the necessities of economic austerity but also, I suspect, because Downing St  realised that Quilliam’s message wasn’t gaining traction with Muslims (and especially those vulnerable to radicalisation) and its impact on the ground was zero or minimal.

So with the dosh no longer readily available Ed Husain buggered off to the right-wing Council of Foreign Relations in America and Quilliam had to cut back on its staff and projects.

Meanwhile, Maajid Nawaz had time to pen a rather naff and vain autobiography and has announced he will stand as  a Liberal Democrat candidate at the next general election.

Yet Quilliam soldiered on, with less media attention and less obvious fanfare, but with the occasional blitz of publicity like yesterday’s fun-and-games with Tommy Robinson. It’s no longer the constant, offensive in-your-face presence it once was, but it’s still occasionally bloody annoying.

Failure

So why did Quilliam fail?

Firstly, Muslims don’t like seeing other Muslims going on national TV and the right-wing media constantly criticising their own while sucking up to the establishment. Even Muslims (like myself) who believe it’s necessary for us to look in the mirror quickly get turned off with relentless self-hating.

Secondly, the facts that Quilliam had no grassroots support, were hardly seen at community events (probably for their own protection), and were artificially created and amplified by  government finances made them transparent frauds in the eyes of the community.

Ed Husain

Ed Husain

Thirdly, they probably annoyed a lot of  “sell-out” Muslim organisations who were also after government money but couldn’t get it because Quilliam had cornered the market.

In many ways this was a shame because the Muslim community is getting more radicalised and insular as the years pass by and its relationship with the British state is getting more problematic.

And there is a need for an organisation which has roots in the community, is loyal to it, is critical of the government and Islamophbia, yet also still seeks to address the real problems that exist in the community itself.

But Quilliam – which is unrepresentative, disloyal and compromised by government finances – certainly ain’t that organisation.

Islamophobia

So I found myself watching the “Tommy and Maajid” show yesterday with a permanent ironic smile.

Here were two people who were theoretically polar opposites but who in reality are basically the same – extremists posing as moderates who should be given a medal by the Queen for services to Islamophobia.

But you know what, I think I prefer Tommy Robinson’s blatant, ignorant retarded form of Islamophobia to Maajid Nawaz’s subtle, suave and sophisticated version.

@RMSalih

Sources
5Pillarz

 

Tags

Facebook Comments

comments

Video Player

VIDEO: Asim Qureshi on the CTS Bill #StopTheBill

In this video, Research Director for Cage, Asim Qureshi, briefly explains the dangers posed by the Counter-Terrorism and Security Bill if it becomes l

VIDEO: Shaykh Shams Ad Duha’s khutbah on the CTS Bill

Shaykh Shams Ad Duha of Ebrahim College discusses the Counter-Terrorism and Security Bill, and what it means for British Muslims. Shaykh Shams Ad Duha

VIDEO: Freedom of speech and Islam? #DontHateDebate

This short documentary is part of the Islamic Education & Research Academy’s (iERA) new campaign ‘Don’t Hate, Debate!’ in

VIDEO: Speaking to French people about #ChalieHebdo cartoons

Imran ibn Mansur aka ‘Dawah Man’ speaks to French people and their views on Charlie Hebdo’s cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad (saw).

Islamophobia Awards 2015: Get voting!

Centred around a gala dinner, the Islamophobia Awards have both a light-hearted and a serious side – to be entertaining and to raise awareness o

A satirical video commentary on the BBC’s “British Islam” Panorama – Part 2

Ibrahim Khan satirically dissects the recent BBC Panorama programme on the “need to reform” British Islam. Khan argues that the programme was Isla

A satirical video commentary on the BBC’s “British Islam” Panorama – Part 1

Ibrahim Khan satirically dissects the recent BBC Panorama programme on the “need to reform” British Islam. Khan argues that the programme

Jummah prayers held in Nottingham for Charlie Hebdo victims

Worshippers gathered at The Karima Centre Mosque in Nottingham for Jummah led by Imam Dr Musharraf Hussain to mourn for the victims who died in Paris

VIDEO: Ali Dawah’s ‘apology experiment’

Ali Dawah and Imran ibn Mansur (Dawah Man) hit the streets of London with their ‘apology experiment’ in response to Rupert Murdoch’s

Idiot Fox News pundit says Birmingham is “totally Muslim”

A self-proclaimed terrorism expert who told Fox News that Birmingham was a “totally Muslim” city where “non-Muslims just simply don’t go” ha

VIDEO: 5 times France really cared about #FreedomOfSpeech

A video collage showing five examples of France’s hypocrisy and double standards when it comes to freedom of speech. This video was made by Raza

Uthman Badar: “God and Prophets should be protected from insult”

In light of the Charlie Hebdo inc, and the ongoing debate on freedom of speech and the ‘right to offend’, this is Uthman Badar’s ope

Attackers shout “Allahu Akbar” during Charlie Hebdo assault

Videos are emerging of the deadly Charlie Hebdo attack which killed 11 people in Paris earlier today. This video shows the black-hooded attackers shou

Dilly Hussain on RT News: Spying on Muslim toddlers is an “absolute joke”

Deputy editor of 5Pillars, Dilly Hussain discusses the Home Office’s expectation of nursery teachers to report Muslim toddlers for terrorist and

VIDEO: Interview with Omar Regan on ‘American Sharia’ movie

Penny Appeal, the Muslim charity that is hosting the “American Sharia” UK tour speak to Omar Regan, the lead actor of the new action-comed

VIDEO: Activist Laura Stuart reflects on her Mavi Marmara experience

The name “Mavi Marmara” is known to millions around the world because of the heroism of ordinary civilians in resisting the supposedly “elit

PROMO: Criminalising Islam series on Iqra TV

The trailer to the upcoming ‘Criminalising Islam’ series on Iqra TV, which include lectures delivered by deputy editor of 5Pillars Dilly H

Penny Appeal presents Muslim “Halalywood” film “American Sharia”

This is the trailer to the first Muslim action-comedy film, “American Sharia” presented by Penny Appeal. Numerous prominent Muslim persona

VIDEO: Frankie Boyle explains why he supports Shaker Aamer campaign

Comedian and writer, Sara Pascoe speaks to Frankie Boyle outside Parliament about his reasons for supporting the campaign for Shaker Aamer’s rel

VIDEO: Sheikh Abdullah Bukhari shot dead in Istandbul

Security camera footage showing the moment a prominent Uzbek scholar was killed in Istanbul. Sheikh Abdullah Bukhari is believed to have been assassin

VIDEO: True Story behind Team Adam Saleh and Dawah Men “beef”

Over the past week, there has been a heated war embroiling on social media between a controversial American YouTuber and London-based “Dawah men”.

Nouman Ali Khan’s khutbah on Pharaoh and Peshawar school attack

Nouman Ali Khan draws comparisons between the story of Musa (as) and Pharaoh in light of the Peshawar school massacre.  This khutbah was delivered on

Boko Haram’s leader Abubakar Shekau “spits freestyle” takfir

In this comical yet extremely worrying video, the leader Boko Haram, Abubakar Shekau makes blanket takfir on numerous Muslim group, rendering them “

Tunisia: Between Islam and Secularism

With the second round of presidential elections due to take pace on December 21 Tunisia is often described as the only Arab revolution success story.