Egypt and the “Emperor with no clothes”

Hosni Mubarak has been released from jail

News that former president Hosni Mubarak has been released from jail demonstrated that the regime has removed its final fig leaf, the emperor revealed with no clothes, writes Dr Reza Pankhurst who was a political prisoner under Mubarak for nearly four years.

All other fig leaves covering the removal of former President Morsi have already been dropped – the unverified 22 million petition signatories, the ludicrous 17-33 million who apparently turned up in Tahrir shown to be a wildly exaggerated figure, the “liberal” Mohammad el-Baradei now holed up in Vienna having fulfilled his role as coup-enabler in front of the West, the fallacy of a neutral technocratic government led by Hazem el-Beblawi (more concerned with fighting “terrorism” than rebuilding the economy) and the idea that Tamarrod was a populist movement (now exposed as Nasserist fascists whose role is to echo and amplify every word of the regime).

The claim that the coup backers were not simply anti-Islamic has also been shown empty once the Salafi  al-Nur party were exposed as “useful idiots” and after it was admitted that all of the facilitators and financiers of the coup ranging from businessman Naguib Sawaris to the Gulf regimes and Saudi Arabia are openly aggressive towards “political Islam.” This is aside from the open support of former Prime Minister Tony Blair, the current Israeli government and the Israeli lobby in Washington among others.

The old system remains in place untouched by the 2011 uprisings, with opposition back behind bars on trumped up charges, with thousands killed, jailed, tortured or pursued by the authorities. Now the regime claims that it is pursuing a “war on terrorism” against internal opposition – the rhetoric is not new, but a return to that of the 1990s. As mentioned by one Egyptian General to Le Monde : “We are 90 million Egyptians and there are only 3 million Muslim Brotherhood. We need six months to liquidate or imprison all. This is not a problem, as we have already done in the 1990s.”

The propaganda machine is in full throttle, with an unquestioning state and private media reminiscent of the pre-2011 era. A war against the “Islamists” has been declared, and the secular illiberal dictatorship regime previously fronted by Mubarak has fully re-emerged from the shadows, feeling itself strong enough to discard itself of any other pretensions.

The US

Despite the handwringing from certain quarters in Washington, this is no bad thing as far as the American government is concerned. Mubarak’s Egypt was one of America’s closest partners in its ongoing “war on terror,” with close intelligence ties and the Egyptian regime provided locations for rendition victims to be “interrogated” as well as providing “interrogators” for others.

Sign up for regular updates straight to your inbox

Subscribe to our newsletter and stay updated on the latest news and updates from around the Muslim world!

While Mubarak’s release is be a major embarrassment, and no one will be encouraging any possible political return for the previously discarded dictator, it should be noted that at the time of the 2011 uprisings ex-Vice President Dick Cheney called Mubarak their “good friend”, President Obama stated that he was their preferred “force for stability and good” and Senator John McCain publicly lamented his removal. Whether he is released in the next few days or not, the symbolism speaks volumes about the current trajectory in Egypt. While Mubarak is clearly passed his sell-by date, in General Sisi the American’s have a newer, more popular model as their point man in Cairo.

As Secretary of State John Kerry let it slip – removing former President Mohammad Morsi was a step towards “restoring democracy.” Or in other words, restoring a regime that would not only agree to protect American interests in the region such as the Camp David accords, but would also work hard to restrict the space for Islamic political activism among the Egyptian public, something that the Morsi administration was ultimately unwilling to do. And so, while the blood flows and the prisons fill in Egypt we are likely to hear very little other than the mumbling of empty condemnation from the “West,” similar to their empty protestations against the Syrian regime of Bashar al-Assad – another former close ally in the “war on terror.”

While the killing of Muslims in such numbers and brazenly open manner in both Egypt and Syria may be too embarrassing for the American government to maintain openly friendly relationships while the unrest continues, ultimately the policies of killing “terrorists” is a shared one, whether silently and away from the cameras by drone attacks in Pakistan and Yemen or crudely by asphyxiation in the back of a police van.


Add your comments below

Previous articleTravelling Muslims experience the “Miranda” treatment
Next articleIs making dua enough?