Moazzam Begg: Obama’s hypocrisy over Mandela

Barack Obama won the overall prize

Director of human rights group CagePrisoners, Moazzam Begg, argues that whilst US president Barack Obama was “deeply humbled” on a recent visit to Nelson Mandela’s prison cell in Robben Island, he unashamedly keeps 166 people detained without trial for 11 years in Guantanamo Bay.

Perhaps some people might not see the parallels between the prison camps at Guantanamo Bay in Cuba and Robben Island off the coast of Cape Town in South Africa, but to former prisoners accused of being terrorists the irony of the US President’s visit to the latter couldn’t be starker.

President Barak Obama, however, has more in common with “terrorists” – past and present – than he cares to admit. During a recent visit to the Robben Island prison, accompanied by his family, former constitutional lawyer Obama declared that he and his family were “deeply humbled” after having walked into Nelson Mandela’s former prison cell and contemplating what life must have been like for the man once branded a “terrorist leader” by the West.

What Obama may not understand – or like to admit – is that the man he openly admires so much was only taken off a US terror list just 6 months before he took office as the President of the USA in 2009.

Mandela was branded a terrorist
Mandela was branded a terrorist

But it is not just being statesmen of African origin that Mandela and Obama have in common: both too have been recipients the Nobel Peace Prize.

The irony may be lost again but the former received it for achieving equality and relative peace after decades of personal sacrifice entailing imprisonment and abuse, while the latter sacrificed the lives of thousands and continued the false imprisonment and abuse of others without any personal loss.


Sign up for regular updates straight to your inbox

Subscribe to our newsletter and stay updated on the latest news and updates from around the Muslim world!

Anwar al-Awlaki

What may be less known is the views of suspects in the current US-led war on terror like those of Yemeni-American Imam Anwar al-Awlaki, the alleged Al-Qaeda ideologue who was killed in 2011 – along with his 16-year old son and one other US citizen– in a highly controversial extra judicial drone strike ordered by President Obama.

At the end of a telephone interview with al-Awlaki in 2007, shortly after his release from detention without trial in Yemen, he asked me for two things: a copy of my book Enemy Combatant and Nelson Mandela’s autobiography Long Walk to Freedom.

Though he felt uncomfortable elaborating al-Awlaki told me that FBI agents came to interrogate him in during his imprisonment in Yemen:

“There was some pressure, which I refused to accept and that led to a conflict that occurred between me and them [FBI], because I felt that it was improper behaviour from their behalf. That led to an issue between me and them during the interrogation.”

I believe the effects of this interrogation adversely affected Anwar al-Awlaki and led directly to his collision course with the US.

“Negotiating with terrorists”

In reality though, Nelson Mandela was convicted by the apartheid regime of South Africa for leading the militant group Umkhonto we Sizwe (Spear of the Nation) while his inspiration had come Che Guevara and Fidel Castro.

Mandela was branded a terrorist not just by the regime that imprisoned him but by western leaders like Margaret Thatcher who referred to him and the African National Congress (ANC) as terrorists.

Guantanamo Bay, Cuba
Guantanamo Bay, Cuba

It’s not that they won’t negotiate with terrorists as both Margaret Thatcher and Tony Blair stated in the past, it just depends on who they are, if they’ve been sufficiently demonised, if they have political support on the ground or if they simply cannot be defeated.

Cue US advocating official talks with the Taliban, office opening in Qatar and senior British military commanders declaring talks with them “were needed a decade ago.” Who knows, perhaps Mullah Omar may be in for a Nobel Peace Prize himself one day?

A couple of years ago former Guantanamo prisoner Mullah Abdul Salam Zaeef, who had been the Taliban spokesman and ambassador to Pakistan in the years preceding and up to the 9/11 attacks, came to the UK for a visit.

When I heard he was over I went to see him. He told me that after his release US Army commander General Petraeus came to his Kabul home to try and find a way to talk to the Taliban.

Zaeef replied that he was no longer part of the group but that if Petraeus did want to locate them all he had to do was follow the trajectory of the missiles and shells they were directing at the Taliban everyday and he would eventually find them, waiting to converse in whatever language he understood.

The circumstances may well be different but the principles are the same in the case of Gerry Adams and Martin McGuiness with their IRA connections and Nelson Mandela with his Spear of the Nation. “Terrorists” can and always have been talked to.

War on terror

Nonetheless, it is easy to see why the idea of Mandela’s legacy is attractive to many. Perhaps Fidel Castro says it best: “If you want an example of a firm, valiant, heroic, serene, intelligent and capable man, this example, this man, is Mandela”.

Thus, becoming Mandela-friendly by erecting statues outside buildings where parliamentary leaders once described him as a terrorist is not enough to rewrite Britain’s role in supporting apartheid, even if the great man did forgive them.

But to me Mandela will always be the man who simply stood up against the system and spent 27 years in prison for a cause certain countries did not support. Those same countries, albeit in different guises, now lead a new war – the war on terror on the Muslim world and Obama is their leader.

Before leaving Mandela’s former prison President Obama wrote in the visitor’s book: “The world is grateful for the heroes of Robben Island, who remind us that no shackles or cells can match the strength of the human spirit.” He must have been in a hurry as he forgot to add “unless you’re shackled in our cells.”

But Obama doesn’t do irony.

The full article can be read on the link below:

Add your comments below

Previous articleSomali man cautioned after Liverpool mosque bomb scare
Next articleChannel 4’s adhaan broadcast is good for community relations